I have an affinity for Joe’s Pizza, on carmine street, I know it’s not “top tier” but their pizza is always consistent and Ive been going there my whole life.
If you’re lucky enough to have the father or son make the pizza it’s always on point.
by Embarrassed_Ad7801
38 Comments
Fini or Mama’s Too
Made in NY
I mean Pizza in NY has a lot about geography. Going to Film Forum this is the place to stop by.
Undoubtedly has something to do with the fact that I live relatively nearby but I stand by New Park Pizza on Cross Bay Blvd in queens.
It actually is “top tier”
Ledo’s
Denino’s is my lifetime favorite because I grew up on it but L’industrie might be my bias aside pick
John’s on bleecker
Angelos coal fired pizza. I don’t like joes
Lenny’s and John’s on Flatbush
Its not good to talk about religion
I’m a big fan of Paulie Gee’s, I think it is orders of magnitude better than Screamers (if you’re after vegan pizza).
Lucia’s
John’s on Bleecker will always be my #1
Song’ E Napule makes a killer Neopolitan
Bleecker st pizza
Lindustrie (accepts hate)
This argument always comes down to where people live or pizza places they regularly have access to.
L’industrie and Mammas Too are my top 2
18th ave in bensonhurst has J&V and DaVinci’s: two iconic brooklyn classics
L and B spumoni or L’industrie. La rose in cobble hill is rising as we speak too
I’m a growing fan of Brooklyn D.O.P. Biased since I live in walking distance of it. Joe’s is great too.
Krispys on 13th Avenue in Brooklyn
Luigi’s in Park Slope
Peppino’s in Bay Ridge, Julianna’s, John’s of Bleecker Street, L&B, Bleecker Street, Scarr’s, Unregular and Joe’s (which is absolutely top-tier)
Mano’s in Ridgewood. It was great when Dom was making pies at DiFara back in the day.
Di Fara
Joe’s is decent, but the sauce is a little sweet for me.
How has no one said Scarr’s?
Pizzeria Suprema
Lucali in Carroll Gardens
Sienna’s
John’s on Bleecker
2 Bros
Amore’s in Flushing
Native NYer here and frankly L’Industrie is perfect, with or without the hype.
Can’t believe no one mentioned new park pizza in howard beach. Best pizza around.
Lucalis or Best Pizza in Williamsburg, different styles tho
Lucali