Love that Luigi’s is the last logged. Ending on a great note 👏
huhzonked
This was so interesting go through.
studmuffffffin
Top 10:
Gramercy Tavern
MeadowSweet
Joe’s
Ayat
Pisillo
Los Tacos No 1
Shiki Omakase
The Nuaa Table
L’Industrie
Yemen Cafe
________________________________
Top 5 Pizza:
Joe’s
L’Industrie
John’s
L&B
Grimaldi’s
lenolalatte
i’ve been here for 10 and i don’t think i even come close to 250…props to you! good luck with your move!
sidenote
Respect. This is a New Yorker’s list – lots of neighborhood joints and more under the radar stuff alongside institutional spots. As you said it’s not comprehensive by any means but cool to see nonetheless!
deathsycthehe11
Whats your go to in Bay Ridge? I’m surprise you didn’t try Thanh Đa, is the locals favorite spot (better than Ba Xuyên).
iggy555
You’re missing tavola
zanzil21
Seeing Pho Hoai get rated as “bad” hurts my heart – it was the first place I tried Vietnamese food, and my go to spot for a while – but about 20 years ago lol
I need to go back soon for the sake of memories
beernerd6
I’ve been here for 8 and have been to 1200
_TheConsumer_
2/20/23 – Should be Roll n Roaster (listed as Rock n Roaster)
Also, you should try Brennan and Carr before you leave!
P0stNutClarity
Nothing in Flatbush 🧐 you scared bruh?
[deleted]
[removed]
Yesathrowguy
Thank you. This is generous and a good resource. I used to work downtown but have been in Midtown now hybrid for six months. This list is helpful.
Deez2Yoots
I’m glad you gave Ayat an “excellent” rating. Anything less than that would have invalidated all your other scores IMO.
harborq
Thanks for the list! For Time Out Market and Queens Night Market, we don’t know where you actually ate. Which station did you pick that was just good? Surely you didn’t try everything… also you really missed out on Queens. Some of the best food in the city is there.
nippyhedren
The fine dining is sending me. But this is awesome. Thanks for sharing!
ktg1975
Fraunces Tavern listed as fine dining is amusing…since that was just the after work pub when I worked in the financial district years ago.
Good list, thanks for sharing.
FR4NCESTHEMUTE
Aska will probably have an open reservation. Would recommend you ending your time in NYC there.
Old-Scene2963
Comedy ” Its a New Yorkers list ” been in the city for two years. LMFAO however I do appreciate this list.
yawantsomeoystersnow
Ah yes, the one and a half boroughs of NYC.
Hisuinooka
thanks so much! Cannot believe you have it this organized. Two questions 1. Where are you leaving to, 2. Are you happy about leaving?
79Impaler
Dyker Park Bagels has been on my list for ages. Gonna check it out this week.
whoisjohngalt72
How did Los tacos make top 10? Jesus you’re a tourist
Fluid_Spend_6729
You’re missing a few great bay ridge spots!
Genos
Ponte Vecchio
Tanoreen
Elia
Automatic-4thepeople
I don’t see any steakhouses on here, are you not a fan or am I overlooking them?
ChoiceCut6655
hope you get to live there again! good luck on your next adventure
mbnyc1118
God tier list. Great work.
I’d love to see another column for the check total at each lol
Practical_Jelly_8342
Crazy been in nyc for almost 30 years and I’ve only been to a handful of these, and never even heard of the others. I guess that ahow just how many places there are here
29 Comments
Obviously missing huge swaths of the city. Harlem, Bronx, most of Queens, Staten Island. The only one on the upper east side is now closed.
But I feel like I hit a lot of the best the city had to offer. I plan on hitting up a couple of my favorites this weekend before I ship out on Monday.
I love this city and I hope I can come back and live here again some day. Maybe next time in Queens or Harlem so I can try more delicious food.
And [here](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PKa0Emex4Q_qd0_ocgit9QEHEwmFv5L6wuXXSsbqFPY/edit?usp=sharing) is the list in excel format.
Love that Luigi’s is the last logged. Ending on a great note 👏
This was so interesting go through.
Top 10:
Gramercy Tavern
MeadowSweet
Joe’s
Ayat
Pisillo
Los Tacos No 1
Shiki Omakase
The Nuaa Table
L’Industrie
Yemen Cafe
________________________________
Top 5 Pizza:
Joe’s
L’Industrie
John’s
L&B
Grimaldi’s
i’ve been here for 10 and i don’t think i even come close to 250…props to you! good luck with your move!
Respect. This is a New Yorker’s list – lots of neighborhood joints and more under the radar stuff alongside institutional spots. As you said it’s not comprehensive by any means but cool to see nonetheless!
Whats your go to in Bay Ridge? I’m surprise you didn’t try Thanh Đa, is the locals favorite spot (better than Ba Xuyên).
You’re missing tavola
Seeing Pho Hoai get rated as “bad” hurts my heart – it was the first place I tried Vietnamese food, and my go to spot for a while – but about 20 years ago lol
I need to go back soon for the sake of memories
I’ve been here for 8 and have been to 1200
2/20/23 – Should be Roll n Roaster (listed as Rock n Roaster)
Also, you should try Brennan and Carr before you leave!
Nothing in Flatbush 🧐 you scared bruh?
[removed]
Thank you. This is generous and a good resource. I used to work downtown but have been in Midtown now hybrid for six months. This list is helpful.
I’m glad you gave Ayat an “excellent” rating. Anything less than that would have invalidated all your other scores IMO.
Thanks for the list! For Time Out Market and Queens Night Market, we don’t know where you actually ate. Which station did you pick that was just good? Surely you didn’t try everything… also you really missed out on Queens. Some of the best food in the city is there.
The fine dining is sending me. But this is awesome. Thanks for sharing!
Fraunces Tavern listed as fine dining is amusing…since that was just the after work pub when I worked in the financial district years ago.
Good list, thanks for sharing.
Aska will probably have an open reservation. Would recommend you ending your time in NYC there.
Comedy ” Its a New Yorkers list ” been in the city for two years. LMFAO however I do appreciate this list.
Ah yes, the one and a half boroughs of NYC.
thanks so much! Cannot believe you have it this organized. Two questions 1. Where are you leaving to, 2. Are you happy about leaving?
Dyker Park Bagels has been on my list for ages. Gonna check it out this week.
How did Los tacos make top 10? Jesus you’re a tourist
You’re missing a few great bay ridge spots!
Genos
Ponte Vecchio
Tanoreen
Elia
I don’t see any steakhouses on here, are you not a fan or am I overlooking them?
hope you get to live there again! good luck on your next adventure
God tier list. Great work.
I’d love to see another column for the check total at each lol
Crazy been in nyc for almost 30 years and I’ve only been to a handful of these, and never even heard of the others. I guess that ahow just how many places there are here