This is actually my best pie to date…I guess I’ll stick with cookies

by WonderNurseEm

37 Comments

  1. It may not be perfect but I would definitely not turn down a slice or more of this pie. That crust has the best color. Please don’t give up on pie baking. This one looks delicious!

  2. Impossible_Dance_853

    It doesn’t have to look perfect to taste delicious 😋

  3. TheBoanne

    Get out some scissors and trim up the edges a little bit… then dust with powdered sugar. 10/10

  4. Consistent-Laugh606

    The pie still looks really tasty ngl

  5. Charlietango2007

    Hi, my baking looks worse but I really don’t care as long as it tastes great. No, I don’t make Martha Stewart camera quality baked goods, but if you’re putting your heart into it, that’s all that matters. Baking relaxes me and I get excited about the end result. Which for me is how something tastes, not looks like. You’re going to cut it up anyways. I rather have my average looking pies that tastes great, rather than a beautiful pie that has very little flavor at all or tastes artificial. Okay I hope this helps. Wishing you courage and luck, hang in there. Have a great day baking

  6. RingingInTheRain

    Your crust could’ve been much much worse. Looks like you ran out of top crust. Remember to seal with egg wash or something similar. Also good crust takes patience. Going to be practicing more crusts myself.

  7. thoughtfractals85

    I can’t bake a pretty pie to save my life, but the taste is what matters! It’s really not too bad looking compared to some of mine, I promise! I’m sure it tastes great.

  8. Flimsy-Citron2225

    You Learn Though Experience; especially if you are willing to give only another phototops type-of-food.

  9. SaaSyGirl

    What kind of pie is it? Looks like some type of berry? Warm it up with some vanilla ice cream and I bet it’s delicious! There’s no such thing as bad pie in my book

  10. luluzinhacs

    as a pie maker, you make beautiful cookies

    but perfection demands time!! keep on trying and you will get there, just as you did with your cookies

  11. Ok-Safe7953

    Looks good enough. Bet it tastes good too. Practice makes perfect. If at 1st you don’t succeed? Give me the pie and try try again. 🙃👍

  12. PanhandlersPets

    Some of the best pies I ever made looked like a mess. How did it taste?

  13. m4rceline

    If you made your pie dough with all butter, it’s never going to be pretty. But it will always taste infinitely better than a decorative crust made with shortening.

  14. Hot-Evidence-5520

    Just slap some ice cream on the slices. No one will be the wiser. 🤤

  15. PaleontologistClear4

    Perfection is overrated unless you’re trying to win a contest or something, that looks amazing and delicious, what’s more important is how it tastes and makes you feel when you eat it.

  16. Nervous_Tiger_7791

    I think your pie looks great! Practice makes perfect!

  17. Krazziegirl

    Doesn’t matter how bad it looks as long as it tastes good 🙂

  18. fuzzynyanko

    Bah. Slice it up and cover it with ice cream, and it’ll be good. Heck, slice it up and don’t cover it with ice cream and it’ll be good as well

  19. Gravity_Freak

    Taste! How does it taste? More important than looks.

  20. Unicorntella

    Ok but drop the cookie recipe?? Those look amazing!

  21. pamelahoward

    Reminds me of a Dragon Ball, and looks delicious!

  22. Truman_Show_Place

    I’ll go with the obvious and say you’re a star! While the top may be slightly askew, it’s still pretty. Practice makes perfect if that’s what you seek. In the meantime, any one who would turn down a slice of that would be crazy imho.

  23. 20milliondollarapi

    The best part about baking is that you get to eat the ugly ones.

  24. Comma_Karma

    I made a pie once. It was good! But never again. Yours looks better than mine did.

  25. sangresangria13

    Well crusts are difficult to really get right and takes practice. Even seasoned bakers will have the fruit juices run a bit. Cookies are definitely my favorite thing to bake too!

  26. AnthonyTyrael

    I’m imperfect too. I believe the taste is great. So you’d easily find me going for a piece.

Write A Comment