First time trying an ice cream from United Dairy Farmers gas station. I got their Blue Moo Cookie Dough flavor on a recommendation!

Single scoop in sugar cone. Nice, sizable scoop. Got free in the UDF app with a coupon. Retails $3.25 a scoop, $3.99 a pint, $5.99 for a 48 oz tub.

  • Ice cream base: an appealing blue color. Taste is perhaps your regular cream taste. Not exactly vanilla but similar. They call it “sugar cookie” ice cream but I didn’t get any distinct flavors like that. Wish I did!
  • Density: standard. 2/3 cup is 91 grams weight and 210 calories. Similar to Turkey Hill.
  • Mix in: sugar cookie dough! Standard size pieces. Very good, sugary and buttery taste similar to Subways sugar cookies (discontinued?). The star of the show.
  • Rating: 6.5/10. Really wonderful sugar cookie mix in. Not super much of it. The base could have more flavor.
  • Would repurchase?: Maybe.

Have you ever gotten a UDF Blue Moo Cookie Dough with a lot of cookie dough pieces? I would definitely like that better.

This ice cream has awakened a desire for more ice cream with sugar cookie dough mix ins! Drop your favorites below. I hear this used to be a more popular mix-in in the past? I haven’t had this particular mix in before.

by Hallelujah289

1 Comment

  1. Pugilist12

    That is just wayyyyyy too many ingredients for me.

Write A Comment