First time in a long time cooking a rib eye over charcoal. How’s it look? It tastes very good!
First time in a long time cooking a rib eye over charcoal. How’s it look? It tastes very good!
by MotherShabooboo1974
45 Comments
separate_guarantee2
Rip homie.
Professional-Sweet-3
For most people in this sub it’s overcooked (me included). But at least the sear looks nice…
CrunchyNippleDip
never seen such thick cuts of beef jerky before
GroundbreakingEar450
I’d maybe throw the rest of that in a croc pot with some veggies and cook it on high for 8 hours.
Distinct_Pin_9503
Definitely on the well side of medium well but to each their own, if you enjoyed it that’s all that matters!
EfficientIndustry423
For me, it’s over cooked as fuck. I like a medium or medium rare.
TopDogBBQ
What was your process and what were you aiming for?
Galletan
Although the people in this sub are against steak beyond medium rare, I have to say that a ribeye is gonna be tasty even at medium well. I come from a family who only eats well done steaks, and I would have loved to have a taste of this ribeye as long as the seasoning was good.
SuperMomn
It looks over cooked 😔
Severe_Piano_223
That’s perfect for me! I know majority rules in this sub and they lean more toward medium and lower but this temperature right here is my jam.
ChunkMonkeysMomma
If that’s how you like it then that’s all that matters really- 😜
Charger_scatpack
Way over cooked personally
Llamaisbaebae
Looks finished.
hairyazol
As long as you liked it but for me at least that is way over. Its much tender and juicier if you keep it pink.
FoxCQC
Looks good to me. I’m pretty flexible with how much it’s cooked.
This kind of gives me mixed feelings because I actually have a hard time with the texture of steak that isn’t rare. Like, my body does not want to swallow it. My body would not want to swallow that… but that char looks so nice that I know I’d try anyway and then sit at your table endlessly chewing because I’m afraid I’ll gag if I swallow. Please tell me that those lovely crusty bits were as satisfying as they look. Let me live vicariously through you.
ShnickityShnoo
If you zoom in, enhance, and squint, you can see a little essence of pink left in there.
ssdohc2020
Looks a little raw.
feelin_raudi
Like shoe leather, but I’m glad you enjoyed it.
dancingmale
Overcooked
MechaStewart
I’d say kill it with fire, but that’s been done well already.
Glad you enjoyed, that’s all that really matters 😉
Kidominos25
Overcooked
saucegod
That’s blasphemy
Clusterduck24
Overcooked for sure
Shit_Disturber71
That’s not well done, that’s congratulations
fatogato
Ribeyes can take being overcooked a good amount, like getting around 140°f. These seem to have easily gone closer to 160°f.
It’s all good though. Just gives you an excuse to eat more steak to get it right next time.
Kidhauler55
Looks great to me!
redhayden2007
It’s definitely more cooked than I would enjoy. But if you liked it, then it’s good 👍
Sear looks great. Little overcooked for my taste. But, you cooked for you. And that plate has plenty of juices.
shiftersix
If you’re happy with it, then it looks great
Fuck-MDD
You’re gonna get roasted harder than that shoe on your plate, but take it as constructive criticism and ignore the haters.
CMDR_PEARJUICE
At a restaurant? I’d send it back. Being served this at a friend’s house? Thanks for your generosity, looks (and from your comments, tastes) great!
brownguyy21
It tastes very good!
That’s all that matters!!
Jokesfor_days
Medium well but still juice , fair enough .
analavalanche69
Next time do the EXACT same thing, but cut each step by 30 sec or a minute actually. Possibly 2! And just trial and error. You have a great starting career as your own personal home chef!! Keep at it.
MrStinkPickleJr
Looks awesome! I personally like rare but It still looks fantastic! 10/10
LulzyWizard
It’s cooked all the way to “congratulations.” Glad you still enjoyed it tho
IgnoranceIsYou
Unpopular opinion but I like steak cooked this way
ExtremeMeringue7421
This must be satire
IntroductionSalty222
Hammered
NoAngle2972
It looks dry and chewy. Overdone.
PuzzleheadedWalrus88
Everyone is saying that it’s overcooked but I think it’s perfect! I like my steak well done, idk why everyone’s obsessed with undercooked meat.
45 Comments
Rip homie.
For most people in this sub it’s overcooked (me included). But at least the sear looks nice…
never seen such thick cuts of beef jerky before
I’d maybe throw the rest of that in a croc pot with some veggies and cook it on high for 8 hours.
Definitely on the well side of medium well but to each their own, if you enjoyed it that’s all that matters!
For me, it’s over cooked as fuck. I like a medium or medium rare.
What was your process and what were you aiming for?
Although the people in this sub are against steak beyond medium rare, I have to say that a ribeye is gonna be tasty even at medium well. I come from a family who only eats well done steaks, and I would have loved to have a taste of this ribeye as long as the seasoning was good.
It looks over cooked 😔
That’s perfect for me! I know majority rules in this sub and they lean more toward medium and lower but this temperature right here is my jam.
If that’s how you like it then that’s all that matters really- 😜
Way over cooked personally
Looks finished.
As long as you liked it but for me at least that is way over. Its much tender and juicier if you keep it pink.
Looks good to me. I’m pretty flexible with how much it’s cooked.
https://preview.redd.it/o7y7yqh6o3jd1.jpeg?width=858&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b4f21ba266d7e0deab8c9ab62998a055b838f8b2
Desecrated
This kind of gives me mixed feelings because I actually have a hard time with the texture of steak that isn’t rare. Like, my body does not want to swallow it. My body would not want to swallow that… but that char looks so nice that I know I’d try anyway and then sit at your table endlessly chewing because I’m afraid I’ll gag if I swallow. Please tell me that those lovely crusty bits were as satisfying as they look. Let me live vicariously through you.
If you zoom in, enhance, and squint, you can see a little essence of pink left in there.
Looks a little raw.
Like shoe leather, but I’m glad you enjoyed it.
Overcooked
I’d say kill it with fire, but that’s been done well already.
Glad you enjoyed, that’s all that really matters 😉
Overcooked
That’s blasphemy
Overcooked for sure
That’s not well done, that’s congratulations
Ribeyes can take being overcooked a good amount, like getting around 140°f. These seem to have easily gone closer to 160°f.
It’s all good though. Just gives you an excuse to eat more steak to get it right next time.
Looks great to me!
It’s definitely more cooked than I would enjoy. But if you liked it, then it’s good 👍
https://preview.redd.it/y362fr4704jd1.jpeg?width=2082&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c9904127fd3a8c9d1eaf22e59e0a7acaa9abf36e
Sear looks great. Little overcooked for my taste. But, you cooked for you. And that plate has plenty of juices.
If you’re happy with it, then it looks great
You’re gonna get roasted harder than that shoe on your plate, but take it as constructive criticism and ignore the haters.
At a restaurant? I’d send it back. Being served this at a friend’s house? Thanks for your generosity, looks (and from your comments, tastes) great!
It tastes very good!
That’s all that matters!!
Medium well but still juice , fair enough .
Next time do the EXACT same thing, but cut each step by 30 sec or a minute actually. Possibly 2! And just trial and error. You have a great starting career as your own personal home chef!! Keep at it.
Looks awesome! I personally like rare but It still looks fantastic! 10/10
It’s cooked all the way to “congratulations.” Glad you still enjoyed it tho
Unpopular opinion but I like steak cooked this way
This must be satire
Hammered
It looks dry and chewy. Overdone.
Everyone is saying that it’s overcooked but I think it’s perfect! I like my steak well done, idk why everyone’s obsessed with undercooked meat.