First, let me start off by saying, if you're curious for more best of lists in NYC, you can subscribe to my food newsletter here where I send you the best restaurants, cafes, and happy hour deals directly to your inbox, 3x a week.
That being said, you know you have too much time on your hands when you start going around the city to try different bagel spots to hold a fictitious bagel Olympics.
However, I've finally settled on my top three picks for the best bagels in NYC. Let me know if you agree or think I'm completely off:
1. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company – Big Bagels, Bigger Flavor
Their bagels are not just oversized but literally an explosion of flavor. I had a Sesame Bagel, dark toasted with Scallion Cream Cheese, and literally couldn't believe my taste buds. Although the storefront seems old, this spot is def a gem and takes the cake at number 1.
2. Bagel Works
Upper East Side vibes, Bagel Works is a throwback. What I love about this place is that the bagel is so even, chewy on the inside, slightly crisp on the outside, and generously sized. Like BB they have a variety of schmears so options pretty limitless. Had the Leo, more of a breakfast sandwich but well worth it. Comes in at a close second.
3. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys – A Taste of NYC’s History
Another oldie but goodie is Kossar’s on 367 Grand St. I didn't know this but they've been around since 1936. The bagels here are lighter and fluffier, and if you've never tried a bialy, I would def let Kossar’s Onion Bialy be your introduction.
by Aggressive-Deal2407