https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/elmo-cake/
I just did buttercream eyes/nose because the recipe’s “cake pop” eyes/nose didn’t look very good.

by fuzzypeacheese

24 Comments

  1. AsweetLemon_____

    It’s precious , HAPPY birthday little one

  2. AI-Notarobot-

    No, it looks good. You can easily tell it’s Elmo.

  3. Lili_E-cat

    I know that this cake made ur 2y old smile as wide as Elmo himself. I think it’s perfect and u making it for ur loved one is such a big gift and a beautiful memory.

  4. imnotfocused

    i’m OBSESSED. i was a diehard elmo fan as a little kid. this made me happy.

  5. wannaread1229

    It’s cute! Happy birthday little one 🎂

  6. stillfallingforyou

    It’s adorable! Happy birthday to your little one 🎈

  7. GoonDocks1632

    It looks fantastic! And really, the only one who matters is a 2 year old whom I’m sure was just thrilled to see this.

  8. MamaBear4485

    Flipping well adorable is what this is!

  9. meat_suit_riot

    You say it’s ‘not pretty’ but it looks fantastic. You made a perfect elmo cake your kid loved, sounds like a success to me!

  10. Odd-Kindheartedness

    It’s adorable, you did a fantastic job!

  11. AccountDangerous5005

    Adorable! I used to love my Mom’s homemade birthday cakes. 🥰 You did a great job!

  12. Aggressive_Umpire281

    It is awesome. You did a great job with the consistency of the icing!

  13. anothergilmoregirlie

    So cute! Definitely a core memory

  14. CivilRaisin4361

    Looks great! I had an elmo birthday cake when I was around her age.

Write A Comment