Cooper sharp, fried onion, salt pepper ketchup mayo
by fllngstr
22 Comments
Which_Marionberry770
I honestly thought I was the only person that liked ketchup on my Philly!
jwillystyle77
Needs more ketchup. And pickles.
glassjaw2214
Welp my day has been ruined
UnitedSteakOfAmerica
What a way to ruin a great sandwich r/KetchupHate
2ndharrybhole
Ketchup is controversial (on this sub, not actually irl) but sometimes it works perfectly.
reese81944
An actual cheesesteak!!! OP made my day!!!
deathwish_ASR
now this is a proper cheesesteak, you get this from a papi store?
starbangerpol
Wow I’ve never heard of ketchup being on one. I must try. Looks great
finkleismayor
Finally!
Firebird22x
Love ketchup on a cheesesteak. There was a place in my hometown that did peppers, onions, and fried potatoes, it worked perfectly to bring it all together
DoctorAculaMD
Need to chop the cheese into the steak a bit more before slapping it on the roll. Other than that, 👍
122_Hours_Of_Fear
Ketchup is overhated imo
Vegetable_Burrito
I’ve never had a proper cheesesteak and I love ketchup, I’m going to have to make a trip to Philadelphia to try the genuine article.
[deleted]
[deleted]
WhoWont
I have had it both ways and I love it both ways. Any version of the Philly cheesesteak is fine with me!
chimchimchow
Idk about ketchup on a cheesesteak, feels wrong
Imawildedible
I love Philly posts. Gonna be drama at the bottom no matter what the post is. Sandwich looks bomb. I’d eat it.
Spiritual-Leader9985
Mayo+hot sauce My guilty cheesesteak additions
ThanksForNothingSpez
There is a disconcerting amount of ketchup love in this thread. I thought this was a happy place, and you’re all out here pouring sugary tomato water on your sandwiches. For shame.
VoraciousTofu
Looks a little light on peppers and onions but delish otherwise 🙂
kuebel33
Hard no on the ketchup for me dawg. If anything, mayo is the way for me. Throw on some hots and jalapeños and some pickles with the rest of your stuff though and I’m pumped.
JelloDarkness
Everyone here is so happy to finally see a “real Philly”.. meanwhile every legit philly cheese steak I’ve ever encountered always had the cheese chopped up and incorporated into the steak, not just lazily thrown it on the bottom of what should be an amoroso roll. 🤷🏽♂️
22 Comments
I honestly thought I was the only person that liked ketchup on my Philly!
Needs more ketchup. And pickles.
Welp my day has been ruined
What a way to ruin a great sandwich r/KetchupHate
Ketchup is controversial (on this sub, not actually irl) but sometimes it works perfectly.
An actual cheesesteak!!! OP made my day!!!
now this is a proper cheesesteak, you get this from a papi store?
Wow I’ve never heard of ketchup being on one. I must try. Looks great
Finally!
Love ketchup on a cheesesteak. There was a place in my hometown that did peppers, onions, and fried potatoes, it worked perfectly to bring it all together
Need to chop the cheese into the steak a bit more before slapping it on the roll. Other than that, 👍
Ketchup is overhated imo
I’ve never had a proper cheesesteak and I love ketchup, I’m going to have to make a trip to Philadelphia to try the genuine article.
[deleted]
I have had it both ways and I love it both ways. Any version of the Philly cheesesteak is fine with me!
Idk about ketchup on a cheesesteak, feels wrong
I love Philly posts. Gonna be drama at the bottom no matter what the post is. Sandwich looks bomb. I’d eat it.
Mayo+hot sauce
My guilty cheesesteak additions
There is a disconcerting amount of ketchup love in this thread. I thought this was a happy place, and you’re all out here pouring sugary tomato water on your sandwiches. For shame.
Looks a little light on peppers and onions but delish otherwise 🙂
Hard no on the ketchup for me dawg. If anything, mayo is the way for me. Throw on some hots and jalapeños and some pickles with the rest of your stuff though and I’m pumped.
Everyone here is so happy to finally see a “real Philly”..
meanwhile every legit philly cheese steak I’ve ever encountered always had the cheese chopped up and incorporated into the steak, not just lazily thrown it on the bottom of what should be an amoroso roll. 🤷🏽♂️