Also, fun story from baking: when I made these, there ended up being enough dough for 31 cookies. I had exactly 31 mini Reece’s cups in the bag I bought, as well as exactly 62 googly eyes in the pack I bought. I felt so lucky!
LoveDogLady
these cookies are so cute, they might just scare away my diet!!
CatNDoge42
wow these cookies are so cute. I gotta ask though, are the eyes edible and what did you make them out of?
sbrsbr31
This is genius!! How long did you keep it in the fridge so that the chocolate legs were dry?
SpeakerSame9076
They look like those little soot sprites! Too cute
DonutDonutDee
These just put a big smile on my face. Thanks OP!
kiipiii_
wait these are so cute! i wanted to make something for halloween, just didn’t know what, now i do!
FlourBooks
These are so cute that they’ve just hijacked my weekend baking plans! Thank you for sharing! 💛
ManicMaenads
Ahhh these are adorable!! Love their little googly eyes!!
Sudden_Badger_7663
I don’t have a steady enough hand to make good legs, but I’m going to try anyway!
beautifuljeep
Adorable!
Archryoseraphys
I am SO making these this year. Never came across this blog but I agree with the creator: holiday theme baking is wonderful!!!
coffeejn
Well, you got skills. Good job.
thelanai
I’m going to try and make this with sunbutter! Thank you!
syds_sweets
Omg I have a party coming up this idea is adorable 🥰
Pretend-Art-7837
A couple of those sets of eyes, looked like boobs 🤣
Cici1958
I saved this recipe! So cute!
Healthy-Change6928
So cute! 🥰
Queen_ofawe124
💜
Fancy_Lady_126
awesome, this is so cute
LindenTom250
… this is so super cute…
tortiepants
I hate peanut butter but I love these cookies for you ❤️🙌
Extension-Act-6178
Super cute🤩☺️
rentedlife
These are on the top of the list for this year’s office party. Thank you for posting this before Halloween and for sharing the recipe!
CrispyCelery22
These are SO cute
HuskyLettuce
They’re deranged and I’m arachnophobic, but these made me laugh. Nice job for spooky season!!
HatchingChick
These spiders look like they’re rolling off their asses and I love it
27 Comments
Recipe from [The First Year Blog](https://thefirstyearblog.com/peanut-butter-spider-cookies/)! They got eaten very quickly. 😂
Also, fun story from baking: when I made these, there ended up being enough dough for 31 cookies. I had exactly 31 mini Reece’s cups in the bag I bought, as well as exactly 62 googly eyes in the pack I bought. I felt so lucky!
these cookies are so cute, they might just scare away my diet!!
wow these cookies are so cute. I gotta ask though, are the eyes edible and what did you make them out of?
This is genius!! How long did you keep it in the fridge so that the chocolate legs were dry?
They look like those little soot sprites! Too cute
These just put a big smile on my face. Thanks OP!
wait these are so cute! i wanted to make something for halloween, just didn’t know what, now i do!
These are so cute that they’ve just hijacked my weekend baking plans! Thank you for sharing! 💛
Ahhh these are adorable!! Love their little googly eyes!!
I don’t have a steady enough hand to make good legs, but I’m going to try anyway!
Adorable!
I am SO making these this year. Never came across this blog but I agree with the creator: holiday theme baking is wonderful!!!
Well, you got skills. Good job.
I’m going to try and make this with sunbutter! Thank you!
Omg I have a party coming up this idea is adorable 🥰
A couple of those sets of eyes, looked like boobs 🤣
I saved this recipe! So cute!
So cute! 🥰
💜
awesome, this is so cute
… this is so super cute…
I hate peanut butter but I love these cookies for you ❤️🙌
Super cute🤩☺️
These are on the top of the list for this year’s office party. Thank you for posting this before Halloween and for sharing the recipe!
These are SO cute
They’re deranged and I’m arachnophobic, but these made me laugh. Nice job for spooky season!!
These spiders look like they’re rolling off their asses and I love it