A2Y. Never been a huge fan of cooked fruit. I am intrigued by the cookie dough pie, but key lime is my favorite.
No_Contribution8588
A, 1, X
AlexRyang
B, 2, Y.
Nikkian42
I don’t play by the rules.
AC1
Diggy_Soze
Apple and peach are on the same bar, but lemon meringue and lime meringue are separate!?
Heresy! A pox on all your houses!
Smeetsie11
B 3 W.
westgazer
A 2 Y for sure
baefy07
D,3,Y
randy_justice
Cherry, Key Lime, Apple
Not even close
Equal_You7744
b4w
friendlyblckhottie
B 1 W
sunnykt912
A2W, with Z as a close second
Providence451
Hahaha I would pick the entire last row.
_User_Name_Fail
C1W….though that second row is a Sophie’s Choice of pie eating
zuuzuu
C2Y.
JumpingCoconutMonkey
C1X
Llamalade-
A,4,w but honestly any of the fruit pies except cherry.
lavish_li
B,1,Z
ewok_on_a_unicorn
B4X
CarinasHere
B2Z
OriginalIll4567
A 4 W
Spare_Actuator3936
D 2 Z
Automatic_Serve7901
A2X
gumbysweiner
D1w. Although I wish the raspberry and peanut butter weren’t in the same row.
RoxEnergy89
A4w
kilroyscarnival
I’m a B1X. I love an apple pie, but there seems to be a wide range of apple pies from great to terrible, depending largely I guess on the varieties of apples used, and the filling techniques. Cherry is a personal fave. Raspberry also sounds good. Honestly, have had some too-heavy peanut-butter desserts too. Okay, just B. 🙂
drownedbubble
B2W
To be clear, this is a choice made under duress as ALL was not an option.
xmetalheadx666x
D 1 Y, though it was a tough decision.
No_Preference_333
B, 2, X. Or B, 2, Z but not a huge fan of crumble topping.
Suspicious-Eagle-828
D 1 W
SanDiego_32
C2W
SeaworthinessOk4039
A4Y
Wikadood
A4Z
jackjackj8ck
PECAN
KEY LIME
BANANA CREAM
RogueInsanity90
D 3 W
Jrox0624
A, 3, Y, though I would try 1 as an experiment if offered
Glum_Landscape_8226
C2X
Cupsofcake1318
A2W
CptRoryHarkness87
C4W
muthermcreedeux
D1Y
cynderisingryffindor
A3y
CJgreencheetah
D2X, though I’m not a huge pie person. The lack of pumpkin pie is disappointing lol
50 Comments
C 2 W
C2Z. A good case could also be made for A and 4
B4Z for me, though B4W is a very close second.
My kids (3 and 5yr boys) say: D1Y
A2Z
A1W.
C 1 Y
A2Y. Never been a huge fan of cooked fruit. I am intrigued by the cookie dough pie, but key lime is my favorite.
A, 1, X
B, 2, Y.
I don’t play by the rules.
AC1
Apple and peach are on the same bar, but lemon meringue and lime meringue are separate!?
Heresy! A pox on all your houses!
B 3 W.
A 2 Y for sure
D,3,Y
Cherry, Key Lime, Apple
Not even close
b4w
B 1 W
A2W, with Z as a close second
Hahaha I would pick the entire last row.
C1W….though that second row is a Sophie’s Choice of pie eating
C2Y.
C1X
A,4,w but honestly any of the fruit pies except cherry.
B,1,Z
B4X
B2Z
A 4 W
D 2 Z
A2X
D1w. Although I wish the raspberry and peanut butter weren’t in the same row.
A4w
I’m a B1X. I love an apple pie, but there seems to be a wide range of apple pies from great to terrible, depending largely I guess on the varieties of apples used, and the filling techniques. Cherry is a personal fave. Raspberry also sounds good. Honestly, have had some too-heavy peanut-butter desserts too. Okay, just B. 🙂
B2W
To be clear, this is a choice made under duress as ALL was not an option.
D 1 Y, though it was a tough decision.
B, 2, X. Or B, 2, Z but not a huge fan of crumble topping.
D 1 W
C2W
A4Y
A4Z
PECAN
KEY LIME
BANANA CREAM
D 3 W
A, 3, Y, though I would try 1 as an experiment if offered
C2X
A2W
C4W
D1Y
A3y
D2X, though I’m not a huge pie person. The lack of pumpkin pie is disappointing lol
A 1 Y
A 1 Y