Some fun pizza cookies I made for the family! They’ve been a huge hit and friends and family are asking for some too!

Recipe for all my sugar cookies and icing

Cookies:
2 C white cane sugar
1 1/2C butter, softened
4 eggs
1 ish tsp of vanilla (I measure with the soul)
5C of flour
2 tsp baking soda
1 tsp salt
Chill over night. Bake at 400 for 6-8 minutes

Icing:
4C powder sugar
5-6 tbsp of milk. Start with the lower amount for thicker consistency.
1tsp vanilla
4tbsp of light corn syrup. Adds firmness without being brittle and some shine.

I let them dry under the kitchen ceiling fan for 24 hours before packaging.

by Mevans272

19 Comments

  1. omg how cute are these!!?? woww these are just amazing looking

  2. LucidFrost-

    Good job, I hate it. Those look like olives and I don’t like them on pizza!

  3. Matt-the-Bakerman

    Ummm this is prob the cutest thing ever. Your recipe looks fine but it’s all about the icing techniques to get this look. I’m a wiz at making cookies and icing but not putting them together to make pretty cookies like these. Can you share any techniques or tips for making them come out? I especially want to know how to do the olives because I love olives.

  4. hyliancoffeehouse

    Whoa I thought these were enamel pins before I read what sub they were posted in! Excellent job! So clean.

  5. Tee_Double_M

    These are so good they actually made me crave pizza. (And also cookies.)

  6. StatusVarious8803

    These are the cutest. Soooo adorable

  7. Pointy_Crystals

    Yes! Yes pls! These look amazing! 😋

  8. MinkaBrigittaBear

    These are cute. I wanna eat one just to scramble my brain

Write A Comment