Jeni’s Delivery

I couldn’t stop myself from taking advantage of the free shipping 😭 I’ve already tried Hot Toddy in the past and I really liked it so I picked up a pint, the rest will be the first time that I’m trying! I am a pistachio freak so I expect to love the Pistachio Macaron so I picked up 2 pints 🫣
warning I am sharing these with my boyfriend, so some of the pints have already been demolished🤣

Hot Toddy: I’d give this around an 8/10. I love how smooth the texture is and there is a nice kick of cayenne at the very end.

Boozy Eggnog: 8/10. Again very smooth and veryyyy creamy. The booze is very subtle but still stands out which I appreciate. I usually love a mix in but I could see myself accidentally eating a whole pint of this before realizing what I’ve done.

Pistachio Macaron: 10/10!! This one was very creamy and soft. I love the very recognizable green macaron color swirled with the yellow. Although this is a home run for me, a crunchy mix in like actual pistachios would have really taken it over the edge for me.

White Chocolate Peppermint: I would say this one is a 7/10. Now I say this as a lover of their Savannah Buttermint flavor which I found to be almost identical. Mint ice cream with white chocolate flecks… I was hoping for something a little different with the WCP to set them apart somehow. Either way still very tasty.

Iced Molasses Gingerbread: 100/10 😳 This ice cream is heavenly. The molasses flavor really shines and makes this ice cream dense and rich. The icing swirl is very nostalgic. This makes me feel like I’m in a log cabin in the middle of nowhere snowed in frosting cookies with Santa Claus himself.