If you've been following my confectioners powdered sugar experiment, the results are in and the culprit wasn't quite what I was expecting.

Across the board, testers noticed a floral flavor which clearly pinpointed Mexican Vanilla as the culprit. That wasn’t my only finding, though, which confirmed my suspicion that not all powdered sugar is created equal.

Now, before you ask — Yes, I did make sure to fully clean my equipment with unscented detergent, triple rinsed, and dried everything with a paper towel. No, I don’t have air fresheners in my home and I do not use silicon mats or tools. You can read more about the troubleshooting steps I took to ensure accuracy in Part 1 of my experiment.

The results were confirmed after testing batch 13, which was created using the exact same method, substituting out Mexican Vanilla for clear vanilla extract.

Again, this post isn’t intended for self promotion but to share the results of the experiment. I don’t sell anything on my blog and it is for educational purposes only.

by vaporwavecookiedough

4 Comments

  1. Fed_up_with_Reddit

    Great test but I would never use clear vanilla. It’s almost certainly made from wood pulp. I make my own extract using Madagascar vanilla beans and white rum. (I found the cheap rums less harsh than the cheap vodkas, although you could just use vodka and run it through a charcoal filter a couple of times.)

  2. snapparillo

    I sincerely appreciate your detailed process, documentation and execution.

  3. Then_Routine_6411

    Fantastic and thanks for doing all the hard work!

  4. _vampira

    What brand of Mexican vanilla are you using?

Write A Comment