The ice cream is not smooth, it’s grainy. The cake pieces are okay. Disappointed to say the least. I give it a 5/10.
Blue Bell Gooey Butter Cake:
“Our flavorful cake batter ice cream combined with a Lucious cream cheese swirl and rich gooey butter cake pieces. As delicious as the gooey butter cake made famous in St. Louis!”
by New_Peanut_9924
6 Comments
Blue Bell has lost its luster for me after I tried Oreo cheesecake. ☹️
I don’t eat blue bell since had that problem about 5 years ago the ice-cream had problems
Every masterpiece will have its cheap imitation
The Jeni’s version is better, imo. But Ben and Jerry’s Topped Bossin’ Cream Pie is also good and the ice cream part is similar in flavor to a Gooey Butter Cake.
Get Jenny’s. Best ice cream I have ever had.
I tried a flavor from them recently: krazy cookie dough. It was neon yellow and icky! And I’m very much a cookie dough type gal! I have heard great things about cookie two step though!